Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm News

Maxell Corporation Prevails on Appeal in a Case brought by Smartfish

Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

Date: August 2, 2017

Key Contacts

Back

Scarinci Hollenbeck litigation team successfully prevails on appeal on behalf of its client Maxell Corporation of America in New Jersey Supreme Court

Maxell Corporation Prevails on Appeal in a Case brought by Smartfish

Lyndhurst, NJ – August 2, 2017– Scarinci Hollenbeck successfully prevailed on an interlocutory appeal on behalf of its client Maxell Corporation of America. The appeal included not only a victory in the Appellate Division, but also a successful motion for leave to appeal in the New Jersey Supreme Court, a rarity in commercial cases.

The dispute began in August 2013, when plaintiff Ergowerx International LLC (“Smartfish”) filed a thirteen-count complaint in New York federal court alleging that Maxell wrongfully induced it to enter into a contract for the distribution of Smartfish’s keyboards and mice and then failed to perform under the terms of that contract. The complaint asserted claims for, among other things, breach of contract, fraud, conversion, patent infringement, trademark infringement, and unjust enrichment. On Maxell’s motion, the district court dismissed all but the breach of contract claim, ruling that Maxell’s liability on that claim, if any, did not extend beyond its initial 18-month commitment to purchase the products (Smartfish argued the commitment was a recurring obligation). The district court then declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the matter.

Almost two years later, Smartfish filed a lawsuit in Bergen County Superior Court, reasserting all of its previously-dismissed state law claims, adding a few others, and joining Hitachi America, Ltd. as a party. The trial court denied Maxell’s motion to dismiss on res judicata grounds, finding that the federal court’s dismissal was not an adjudication on the merits and, therefore, the claims were not barred. Maxell moved the Appellate Division for interlocutory review, which was denied. Maxell then moved the New Jersey Supreme Court for interlocutory review, arguing the trial court’s decision “strikes at the integrity of federal judicial power.” In a one-page order, the New Jersey Supreme Court granted the motion and remanded the matter to the Appellate Division.

After briefing and oral argument, on July 26, 2017, the Appellate Division reversed the trial court’s decision and dismissed all claims “with one exception. The breach of contract cause of action can proceed against Maxell, but only as to one eighteen-month term.”

Scarinci Hollenbeck’s Robert E. Levy, Charles H. Friedrich and Roshan D. Shah, along with Hillary Preston and Isabel Sukholitsky, of Vinson & Elkins LLP, represented Maxell.

    No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

    Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

    Related Posts

    See all
    Business Journal NJBIZ Names Ronald S. Bienstock and William C. Sullivan, Jr. Leaders in Law post image

    Business Journal NJBIZ Names Ronald S. Bienstock and William C. Sullivan, Jr. Leaders in Law

    Ronald S. Bienstock and William C. Sullivan, Jr. of Scarinci Hollenbeck Recognized as 2025 Leaders in Law by NJBIZ Little Falls, NJ – March 6, 2025 – One of New Jersey’s leading business journals, NJBIZ, has recognized Ronald S. Bienstock, Partner and Chair of the Intellectual Property Group, and William C. Sullivan, Jr., Partner and […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "Business Journal NJBIZ Names Ronald S. Bienstock and William C. Sullivan, Jr. Leaders in Law"
    Scarinci Hollenbeck Named Among 2025 Best Companies to Work For post image

    Scarinci Hollenbeck Named Among 2025 Best Companies to Work For

    Scarinci Hollenbeck Named in U.S. News & World Report’s 2025 Best Companies to Work For Law Firms Little Falls, NJ  – March 4, 2025 − U.S. News & World Report, the global authority in rankings and consumer advice, has named Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC one of the best law firms to work for in its […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "Scarinci Hollenbeck Named Among 2025 Best Companies to Work For"
    Donald M. Pepe and Donald Scarinci Named to 2025 ROI-NJ Influencers: Law List post image

    Donald M. Pepe and Donald Scarinci Named to 2025 ROI-NJ Influencers: Law List

    ROI-NJ Continues to Feature Donald Scarinci and Donald M. Pepe on Annual Influencers in Law List Little Falls, NJ – February 26, 2025 – Partner and Chair of Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC’s Commercial Real Estate Department Donald M. Pepe and Founding & Managing Partner Donald Scarinci have once again been named to ROI-NJ’s Influencers: Law […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "Donald M. Pepe and Donald Scarinci Named to 2025 ROI-NJ Influencers: Law List"
    Tax, Trusts and Estates Partner Marc J. Comer and Three Senior Associates Join Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC post image

    Tax, Trusts and Estates Partner Marc J. Comer and Three Senior Associates Join Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC

    Tax, Trusts and Estates Partner Marc J. Comer and Three Senior Associates Join Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC Little Falls, NJ – February 20, 2025 – Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC is pleased to announce the addition of one new Partner. The firm also welcomes three Senior Associate attorneys. The expansion strengthens the firm’s capabilities across several practice […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "Tax, Trusts and Estates Partner Marc J. Comer and Three Senior Associates Join Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC"
    Scarinci Hollenbeck Attorneys Launch New BNI Chapter in NYC post image

    Scarinci Hollenbeck Attorneys Launch New BNI Chapter in NYC

    Pioneering Networking Opportunities: James M. Meaney, Jesse M. Dimitro, and Christopher D. Warren Lead Initiative to Enhance Business Collaboration and Growth New York, NY – February 13, 2025 – Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC is proud to announce that James M. Meaney, Jesse M. Dimitro, and Christopher D. Warren have taken the initiative to establish a […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "Scarinci Hollenbeck Attorneys Launch New BNI Chapter in NYC"
    John M. Scagnelli Speaks at Annual Redevelopment Law Institute post image

    John M. Scagnelli Speaks at Annual Redevelopment Law Institute

    John M. Scagnelli Featured as Panelist on “The Impact that the Proposed Resilient Environments and Landscapes (NJ PACT) Regulations will have on Redevelopment” Little Falls, NJ – January 29, 2025 – Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC is proud to announce that Partner John M. Scagnelli, a member of the firm’s Environmental Law section, was recently featured […]

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Link to post with title - "John M. Scagnelli Speaks at Annual Redevelopment Law Institute"

    No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

    Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!

    Explore What Matters Most to You.

    Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

    Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

    Maxell Corporation Prevails on Appeal in a Case brought by Smartfish

    Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

    Scarinci Hollenbeck litigation team successfully prevails on appeal on behalf of its client Maxell Corporation of America in New Jersey Supreme Court

    Maxell Corporation Prevails on Appeal in a Case brought by Smartfish

    Lyndhurst, NJ – August 2, 2017– Scarinci Hollenbeck successfully prevailed on an interlocutory appeal on behalf of its client Maxell Corporation of America. The appeal included not only a victory in the Appellate Division, but also a successful motion for leave to appeal in the New Jersey Supreme Court, a rarity in commercial cases.

    The dispute began in August 2013, when plaintiff Ergowerx International LLC (“Smartfish”) filed a thirteen-count complaint in New York federal court alleging that Maxell wrongfully induced it to enter into a contract for the distribution of Smartfish’s keyboards and mice and then failed to perform under the terms of that contract. The complaint asserted claims for, among other things, breach of contract, fraud, conversion, patent infringement, trademark infringement, and unjust enrichment. On Maxell’s motion, the district court dismissed all but the breach of contract claim, ruling that Maxell’s liability on that claim, if any, did not extend beyond its initial 18-month commitment to purchase the products (Smartfish argued the commitment was a recurring obligation). The district court then declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the matter.

    Almost two years later, Smartfish filed a lawsuit in Bergen County Superior Court, reasserting all of its previously-dismissed state law claims, adding a few others, and joining Hitachi America, Ltd. as a party. The trial court denied Maxell’s motion to dismiss on res judicata grounds, finding that the federal court’s dismissal was not an adjudication on the merits and, therefore, the claims were not barred. Maxell moved the Appellate Division for interlocutory review, which was denied. Maxell then moved the New Jersey Supreme Court for interlocutory review, arguing the trial court’s decision “strikes at the integrity of federal judicial power.” In a one-page order, the New Jersey Supreme Court granted the motion and remanded the matter to the Appellate Division.

    After briefing and oral argument, on July 26, 2017, the Appellate Division reversed the trial court’s decision and dismissed all claims “with one exception. The breach of contract cause of action can proceed against Maxell, but only as to one eighteen-month term.”

    Scarinci Hollenbeck’s Robert E. Levy, Charles H. Friedrich and Roshan D. Shah, along with Hillary Preston and Isabel Sukholitsky, of Vinson & Elkins LLP, represented Maxell.

    Let`s get in touch!

    * The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

    Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!

    Please select a category(s) below: