Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm Insights

Insurer Required To Prove Insured’s Intent To Contaminate

Author: Daniel T. McKillop

Date: December 1, 2017

Key Contacts
Back

Insurer Required To Demonstrate Intent Of Insured To Cause Contamination In Order To Deny CGL Coverage For Environmental Liability

A New Jersey court recently ruled in Cooper Industries LLC v. Employers Insurance of Wausau A Mutual Co. that Cooper Industries is covered by a predecessor’s corporate general liability (CGL) policies for any liability the company incurs regarding Passaic River remediation efforts, including settlement payments. In support, the court determined that the insurers failed to prove that Cooper’s predecessor intended to cause environmental harm “comparable both as to severity and type with that for which indemnification is sought,” thereby negating application of the policies’ pollution exclusions. 

Insurer Must Demonstrate Insured's Intent to Contaminate
Photo courtesy of Tyson Dudley (Unsplash.com)

Environmental Contamination of Passaic River

On March 10, 2010, the EPA issued a General Notice Letter to Cooper Industries LLC, naming Cooper as a “potentially responsible party” (PRP) for environmental remediation of a 17-mile stretch of the Passaic River known as the Lower Passaic River Restoration Project. In the General Notice Letter, the EPA maintained that Cooper was responsible for the cleanup as the successor to the McGraw-Edison Company. The agency also requested that Cooper become a cooperating party by participating in the Cooperating Parties Group Agreement (CPG Agreement), which is a type of settlement between and among the EPA and other potentially responsible parties. The EPA warned that if Cooper declined to join the cooperating group, the agency may initiate enforcement proceedings under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA).

In May 2011, Cooper notified Lamorak Insurance Co. (formerly known as OneBeacon Insurance Company), which Cooper contends issued policies to Cooper’s predecessor, McGraw-Edison, of the EPA General Notice Letter and demanded that OneBeacon provide Cooper with a defense to the EPA action. OneBeacon refused to provide a defense to Cooper for several reasons, among which was their assertion that the policies at issue contained pollution exclusion clauses that precluded coverage related to liability arising from the release of pollutants. As a result, Cooper assumed its own defense and entered into the CPG Agreement.

Cooper subsequently filed a declaratory action against Lamorak and several other insurance carriers seeking indemnification in connection with the EPA action. Cooper maintains that, as a result of the insurers’ failure to provide Cooper with a defense, it has incurred (and is continuing to incur) more than $4.1 million in defense costs.

Insurance Coverage Dispute Over Indemnification

In prior proceedings in Cooper Industries LLC v. Employers Insurance of Wausau A Mutual Co., Judge Garry Furnari held that receipt of the EPA Notice Letter constituted a “suit” that triggered coverage under the policies. In reaching his decision, Judge Furnari noted that the EPA relies on Notice Letters to encourage cooperation, subjecting those who fail to comply to contempt proceedings, fines, and treble damages and barring them from filing a contribution action against settling PRPs. “[G]iven the coercive nature of CERCLA, it would be ‘naive to characterize the EPA letter as a request for voluntary action,” he wrote.

In the latest ruling, the court addressed, among other issues, whether McGraw-Edison Company’s insurers must indemnify Cooper for any future EPA settlement or other financial liability. The court held that Cooper “deserves a ruling declaring that, if Cooper is found liable, then the Insurers owe a duty to indemnify.” Judge Furnari also rejected the insurers’ argument that indemnity claims are premature. “As insurers whose policies provide first-dollar coverage for Cooper’s liabilities, the likelihood that the certain insurers will bear responsibility for some quantum of indemnity costs for the remediation of the Lower Passaic River Site appears to be quite certain,” he concluded.

The court also addressed whether Cooper’s potential liability for pollution of the Lower Passaic River would fall within the scope of coverage provided by the policies. The court ruled that the environmental contamination was not subject to the policies’ pollution exclusion. In reaching his decision, Judge Furnari noted that environmental actions will be treated as alleging a covered occurrence pursuant to a commercial general liability policy unless the insurer can prove that “the insured intended or expected to cause environmental harm comparable both as to severity and type with that for which indemnification is sought.” CPC Int’l., Inc. v. Hartford Acc. & Indem. Co, 316 N.J. Super. 351, 371 (App. Div. 1998).

In this case, the court held that the requirement weighed in favor of Cooper. “There appears to be no evidence that Cooper’s predecessors intended to cause the environmental harm for which Cooper is currently being held liable,” Judge Furnari wrote. “Even the Insurers’ proposed expert on the timing of the contamination here supports the conclusion that the occurrences took place during each of the Policies’ respective coverage periods.” He added: “As a result, these liabilities logically appear to demand being treated as covered occurrences unless the insurers can prove that Cooper’s predecessors intended to cause environmental injury ‘comparable both as to severity and type with that for which indemnification is sought.’”

The court’s decision provides support to insureds seeking coverage for environmental liabilities who can make a claim against predecessors’ policies, even where the policies contain pollution exclusion provisions, as insurers will likely find it difficult to demonstrate the level of a predecessor’s intent required by Judge Funari. However, the unique facts of each individual situation must be carefully considered and discussed by insureds and experienced counsel prior to asserting a claim against insurers on this basis.

If you have any questions or if you would like to discuss the matter further, please contact me, Dan McKillop, at 201-806-3364.

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC
Related Posts
See all
2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know post image
2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know

Federal gift tax rules allow individuals to transfer significant assets to loved ones without incurring gift taxes, but taking full advantage of these opportunities requires an understanding of the applicable limits and deadlines. With the annual gift tax exclusion set to increase in 2027, now is a good time to review the current rules and […]

Author: Marc J. Comer

Link to post with title - "2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know"
BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements post image
BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are being developed throughout New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, with much of the legal attention focused on zoning approvals, permitting, interconnection, and safety requirements. Far less attention has been paid to what happens when these facilities reach the end of their operating lives. For developers and property owners entering […]

Author: Nicholas Wall

Link to post with title - "BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements"
Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know post image
Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know

While most estate and trust administrations conclude without significant complications, disagreements can arise over expenses, fiduciary commissions, distributions, and other aspects of the administration. Understanding the steps involved, as well as the fiduciary’s legal obligations, can help avoid unnecessary disputes and bring the administration to a successful conclusion. Key Takeaways Keeping Beneficiaries Informed Throughout the […]

Author: Marc J. Comer

Link to post with title - "Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know"
Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors post image
Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors

A Fort Monmouth redevelopment agreement imposes obligations beyond a traditional property purchase, including construction deadlines, financial commitments, permitted uses, and restrictions on future transfers. Fort Monmouth’s ongoing redevelopment presents significant opportunities for real estate developers, investors, and businesses seeking to establish or expand their presence in Monmouth County. However, acquiring and developing property at the […]

Author: Donald M. Pepe

Link to post with title - "Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors"
BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners post image
BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners

As battery energy storage system (BESS) projects move from planning to construction, developers and property owners must address an issue that extends well beyond zoning approvals and interconnection agreements: what happens when something goes wrong? To avoid unforeseen liability, developers should address fire code compliance, emergency response planning, contractual risk allocation, and environmental liability before […]

Author: Nicholas Wall

Link to post with title - "BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners"
Rule 26 Expert Discovery: When an Expert Witness Uses AI, Is It Discoverable? post image
Rule 26 Expert Discovery: When an Expert Witness Uses AI, Is It Discoverable?

Case law following the 2010 amendments to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 offers guidance on how courts are likely to address whether an expert witness’s AI records are subject to discovery. Key Takeaways Rule 26 Expert Discovery After the 2010 Amendments This article addresses the question courts and lawyers have faced in recent cases: […]

Author: Chris Seelinger

Link to post with title - "Rule 26 Expert Discovery: When an Expert Witness Uses AI, Is It Discoverable?"

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!
Explore What Matters Most to You.

Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

Let`s get in touch!

* The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form. By providing a telephone number and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging.
“If you would like to submit a file, please email it directly to info@sh-law.com.

Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!