
Partner
201-896-7115 dmckillop@sh-law.comFirm Insights
Author: Daniel T. McKillop
Date: February 7, 2019

Partner
201-896-7115 dmckillop@sh-law.comUnder the equitable doctrine of judicial estoppel, parties are precluded from taking a position in a case that is contrary to a position it has taken in earlier legal proceedings. As explained by the Appellate Division in Cummings v. Bahr, 295 N.J. Super. 374, 387 (App. Div. 1996), “If a court has based a final decision, even in part, on a party’s assertion, that same party is thereafter precluded from asserting a contradictory position.”

In Terranova et al. v. General Electric Pension Trust et al., the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court held that the doctrine of judicial estoppel precluded the owners of a gas station from seeking contribution costs under the New Jersey Spill Compensation and Control Act (Spill Act) from certain defendants because the owners had already obtained a court order holding other parties responsible for the contamination at issue.
In Terranova, Matthew P. Terranova, Karen L. Terranova and New Land Holdings, LLC (“Plaintiffs”), owners of a commercial property long used as a gas station, alleged that former owner-operators General Electric Pension Trust and Atlantic Richfield Company, Amerco Real Estate Company, and Charles Boris, Jr., Carol Boris and Edward Wilgucki (collectively, the “Defendants”) were liable under the Spill Act for contribution toward the cost of clean-up and removal of hazardous substances.
However, Plaintiffs had previously leased the property to Keith Friedman and Michael Puccio, who operated a gas station there from 1981 until 2008. In May 2010, Plaintiffs amended an action filed against Puccio and Friedman related to an escrow agreement, adding claims alleging Puccio’s and Friedman’s environmental contamination of the property, including one for contribution under the Spill Act. The case went to arbitration, and based on conclusions of Plaintiffs’ expert reports, Plaintiffs were awarded $45,000 for expended remediation costs in 2012. Friedman and Puccio were also required to take over the remediation process. Friedman and Puccio failed to fulfill this obligation. Plaintiffs subsequently conducted further studies at the site and concluded that “soil and groundwater contamination . . . associated with the gasoline storage and handling” began on the property “on or before 1963 and continued until… 2000.” On November 10, 2015, the plaintiffs filed the present action against the Defendants based on these new conclusions. During discovery the Defendants became aware of Plaintiffs’ initial litigation against Puccio and Friedman and filed motions for summary judgment, citing judicial estoppel. The court agreed, finding that judicial estoppel prohibits a party from maintaining conflicting positions at different points in litigation and barred Plaintiffs’ Spill Act claims.
Plaintiffs appealed, but the Appellate Division affirmed the trial court’s grant of summary judgment to the Defendants. “Judicial estoppel is a defense to Spill Act claims for contribution and its application was proper under the material circumstances of this case which we now review in the light most favorable to plaintiffs,” the panel held.
In reaching its decision, the appeals court rejected the Plaintiffs’ argument that judicial estoppel is not a recognized defense to Spill Act claims. “Adhering to the [Supreme] Court’s logic, judicial estoppel is not a defense subject to any overriding legislation and, as such, it may be maintained against a Spill Act claim,” the court wrote. “The doctrine is an equitable principle… designed to “prevent litigants from playing fast and loose with the courts,” the appeals court further explained, citing the Third Circuit’s decision in Ryan Operations v. Santiam-Midwest Lumber.
The court went on to conclude that that judicial estoppel precluded the Plaintiffs’ Spill Act claims. “The decision to disregard the possibility that other dischargers — from whom Plaintiffs now seek contribution — were responsible under the Spill Act and pursue only Puccio and Friedman is the type of inconsistent practice necessitating application of the judicial estoppel doctrine,” the appeals court held.
The Appellate Division’s decision makes clear the need for contaminated property owners to identify all potentially responsible parties prior to pursuing any remediation claim under the New Jersey Spill Act. If not, they may be precluded for later seeking contribution from additional parties, even though they may have indeed been responsible for the contamination.
If you have any questions or if you would like to discuss the matter further, please contact me, Dan McKillop, or the Scarinci Hollenbeck attorney with whom you work, at 201-806-3364.
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Federal gift tax rules allow individuals to transfer significant assets to loved ones without incurring gift taxes, but taking full advantage of these opportunities requires an understanding of the applicable limits and deadlines. With the annual gift tax exclusion set to increase in 2027, now is a good time to review the current rules and […]
Author: Marc J. Comer

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are being developed throughout New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, with much of the legal attention focused on zoning approvals, permitting, interconnection, and safety requirements. Far less attention has been paid to what happens when these facilities reach the end of their operating lives. For developers and property owners entering […]
Author: Nicholas Wall

While most estate and trust administrations conclude without significant complications, disagreements can arise over expenses, fiduciary commissions, distributions, and other aspects of the administration. Understanding the steps involved, as well as the fiduciary’s legal obligations, can help avoid unnecessary disputes and bring the administration to a successful conclusion. Key Takeaways Keeping Beneficiaries Informed Throughout the […]
Author: Marc J. Comer

A Fort Monmouth redevelopment agreement imposes obligations beyond a traditional property purchase, including construction deadlines, financial commitments, permitted uses, and restrictions on future transfers. Fort Monmouth’s ongoing redevelopment presents significant opportunities for real estate developers, investors, and businesses seeking to establish or expand their presence in Monmouth County. However, acquiring and developing property at the […]
Author: Donald M. Pepe

As battery energy storage system (BESS) projects move from planning to construction, developers and property owners must address an issue that extends well beyond zoning approvals and interconnection agreements: what happens when something goes wrong? To avoid unforeseen liability, developers should address fire code compliance, emergency response planning, contractual risk allocation, and environmental liability before […]
Author: Nicholas Wall

Case law following the 2010 amendments to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 offers guidance on how courts are likely to address whether an expert witness’s AI records are subject to discovery. Key Takeaways Rule 26 Expert Discovery After the 2010 Amendments This article addresses the question courts and lawyers have faced in recent cases: […]
Author: Chris Seelinger
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
Let`s get in touch!
Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!