Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm Insights

ERISA Does Not Take Precedence Over State Law to Allow Discretionary Clauses

Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

Date: January 26, 2016

Key Contacts
Back

State Law & Discretionary Clauses

The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals refused to hear a case that involved Mary C. Fontaine, a retired equity partner from Mayer Brown LLP, who accused Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. of wrongfully denying her disability benefits.

According to a Bloomberg BNA report, the court ruled that Employee Retirement Income Security Act did not preempt state law which restricted discretionary clauses, and therefore Fontaine was owed disability benefits under the plan. This decision was significant because the court asserted that insurance companies do not have the right to revise health and disability insurance policies based on discretionary clauses listed in ERISA plans.

The background of the case

In the case, Fontaine stated that she was forced to retire due to problems with her vision. Law 360 reported that she claimed that her vision problems qualified under the disability plan listed in the insurance policy. However, when Metropolitan Life Insurance denied her claim because her condition did not fit its disability criteria of the insurance policy, Fontaine sued the company. Her lawsuit alleged that Metropolitan Life Insurance’s determination of ineligibility was conducted at random, and therefore should be subject to an impartial review.

The initial ruling by the Illinois federal court was that state law permitted Fontaine to receive benefits de novo because she had provided enough evidence that proved her disability. Metropolitan Life Insurance argued that ERISA overruled Illinois state law because the denial of disability and insurance benefits was not done at random. Furthermore, MetLife argued that it was entitled to a deferential review and it decision should be given full force and effect because it had discretionary authority under the plan. Therefore, the company sought an appeal of the initial decision.

The appeals court rules in favor of Fontaine

Illinois administrative regulation §2001.3 prohibits discretionary clauses in insurance contracts of the kind relied on by MetLife. The court cited the previous Ninth and Sixth Circuit court decisions which argued that ERISA did not override state laws that prohibit insurance companies to use discretionary clauses in determinations of insurance contracts. Metropolitan Life Insurance opposed the decision because it cited language under the ERISA plan that enabled such discretionary determinations to be made by the insurer. This point was refuted by the court because it determined that if discretionary clauses like this one were allowed to preempt state laws, then there would be nothing to prevent insurance companies from denying all disability claims. It also asserted that such language needed to be in the ERISA plan documents at the time the claimant signed off on them.

Whether Illinois administrative regulation §2001.3 regulates an insurance contract or an ERISA plan determined the level of deference given the decision of MetLife on Fontaine’s claim. The court held §2001.3 regulated an insurance contract issued in the State of Illinois, thus MetLife was not entitled to deference and the matter would be subject to de novo review.

The court ultimately ruled that Metropolitan Life Insurance conducted a negligent denial of Fontaine’s disability claim, and that she should receive the benefits under the terms of the insurance policy.

The significance of the case from a national perspective

The decision follows other cases which hold that an insurance contract may be regulated by a state despite being issued to an ERISA plan. This means that decision of an insurance company denying a claim under an insurance contract will not receive deference that a decision of an ERISA plan administrator might otherwise receive.

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC
Related Posts
See all
Workplace Investigations: How Employers Should Respond When a Complaint Lands post image
Workplace Investigations: How Employers Should Respond When a Complaint Lands

When an employee raises a complaint of harassment, discrimination, retaliation, or other workplace misconduct, an employer’s response can have significant legal consequences. A prompt, impartial, and well-documented workplace investigation can help employers address potential wrongdoing, protect employees, and reduce the risk of costly employment litigation. For New Jersey and New York businesses, understanding when to […]

Author: Angelo Auteri

Link to post with title - "Workplace Investigations: How Employers Should Respond When a Complaint Lands"
2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know post image
2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know

Federal gift tax rules allow individuals to transfer significant assets to loved ones without incurring gift taxes, but taking full advantage of these opportunities requires an understanding of the applicable limits and deadlines. With the annual gift tax exclusion set to increase in 2027, now is a good time to review the current rules and […]

Author: Marc J. Comer

Link to post with title - "2026 Year-End Gift Tax Planning: What You Need to Know"
BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements post image
BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are being developed throughout New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, with much of the legal attention focused on zoning approvals, permitting, interconnection, and safety requirements. Far less attention has been paid to what happens when these facilities reach the end of their operating lives. For developers and property owners entering […]

Author: Nicholas Wall

Link to post with title - "BESS Decommissioning: What Developers and Landowners Need to Address in Long-Term Agreements"
Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know post image
Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know

While most estate and trust administrations conclude without significant complications, disagreements can arise over expenses, fiduciary commissions, distributions, and other aspects of the administration. Understanding the steps involved, as well as the fiduciary’s legal obligations, can help avoid unnecessary disputes and bring the administration to a successful conclusion. Key Takeaways Keeping Beneficiaries Informed Throughout the […]

Author: Marc J. Comer

Link to post with title - "Concluding an Estate or Trust Administration in New Jersey: What Executors and Trustees Need to Know"
Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors post image
Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors

A Fort Monmouth redevelopment agreement imposes obligations beyond a traditional property purchase, including construction deadlines, financial commitments, permitted uses, and restrictions on future transfers. Fort Monmouth’s ongoing redevelopment presents significant opportunities for real estate developers, investors, and businesses seeking to establish or expand their presence in Monmouth County. However, acquiring and developing property at the […]

Author: Donald M. Pepe

Link to post with title - "Fort Monmouth Redevelopment Agreements: Key Contractual Considerations for Developers and Investors"
BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners post image
BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners

As battery energy storage system (BESS) projects move from planning to construction, developers and property owners must address an issue that extends well beyond zoning approvals and interconnection agreements: what happens when something goes wrong? To avoid unforeseen liability, developers should address fire code compliance, emergency response planning, contractual risk allocation, and environmental liability before […]

Author: Nicholas Wall

Link to post with title - "BESS Safety and Emergency Response: Legal Issues for Developers and Property Owners"

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!
Explore What Matters Most to You.

Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

Let`s get in touch!

* The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form. By providing a telephone number and submitting this form you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You can reply STOP to opt-out of further messaging.
“If you would like to submit a file, please email it directly to info@sh-law.com.

Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!