Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm News

NJ Appeals Court: Real Estate Disclosure by Agent Required for Tragic Elevator Accident

Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

Date: September 7, 2015

Key Contacts

Back

A New Jersey appeals court recently clarified the circumstances under which New Jersey real estate disclosure is required for a property’s tragic past. In Petrosino v. Ventrice

A New Jersey appeals court recently clarified the circumstances under which New Jersey real estate disclosure is required for a property’s tragic past. In Petrosino v. Ventrice, the court held that agents were obligated to disclose a tragic elevator accident that claimed the lives of two small children because it was not solely a “psychological impairment.” In addition, disclosure was warranted because the buyers had expressly asked about the safety of the elevator.

The Facts of the Case

Plaintiffs Alexandra and Louis Petrosino purchased a $2,275,000 home in Colts Neck from defendant-sellers Kevin and Grace Ventrice in November 2011. Shortly after the closing, the buyers learned that a tragic and deadly accident occurred on the property involving the house’s elevator.

According to the court’s opinion, when Kevin Ventrice and his daughter and real estate broker, defendant Kimberly Mulligan, were showing the home to Louis Petrosino, he asked Mulligan whether the elevator was safe, citing that he had several small children. Ventrice told Petrosino the elevator was safe and demonstrated how it worked. Mulligan said nothing.

On the explicit advice of Mulligan’s employer, Coldwell Banker Real Estate, L.L.C., Ventrice did not tell Petrosino that two little girls of almost the same ages of his children had died horrible deaths in the elevator after getting trapped between the cab and the wall of the elevator shaft nine years before. After learning of the elevator accident, the plaintiffs had a local elevator company examine the elevator. The elevator mechanic conducted an inspection, explained how the tragic accident had occurred, and told the plaintiffs that he believed that the elevator still posed serious risks.

The plaintiffs moved out of the house and later filed suit. Their complaint alleged that they were completely unaware that two little girls had been crushed to death by the elevator when they purchased the house, that they had specifically inquired of the sellers as to the safety of the elevator, that the sellers falsely represented that the elevator was safe, and that had they known of the accident they would never have purchased the house. The suit named the sellers, as well as both real estate agents involved in the transaction. Claims included negligence, consumer fraud and conspiracy to defraud.

The Legal Background & Real Estate Disclosure

Under N.J.A.C. 11:5-6.4(b), licensed agents must make a reasonable effort to ascertain the physical condition of a property. The statute specifically mandates disclosure of “all information material to the physical condition of any property which they know[,] or which a reasonable effort to ascertain such information would have revealed[,] to their client or principal and when appropriate to any other party to a transaction.”

Pursuant to the New Jersey real estate law, psychological impairments, such as “a murder or suicide which occurred on a property, or a property purportedly being haunted,” are not considered information which affects the physical condition of a property. However, when asked by a prospective buyer, real estate disclosure is required for whatever information they know about the…psychological impairments that might affect the property.”

The Court’s Decision

The Appellate Division rejected the real estate brokers’ contention that the children’s deaths in the elevator in 2002 represented only a “psychological impairment” to the Colts Neck property, which they were under no duty to disclose. According to the appeals court, the defendants “misapprehend both the nature of the condition and their duties to plaintiffs.”

In reaching its decision, the appeals court noted that “[t]he issue is not only that two children perished on the property but that they died by being crushed in the malfunctioning elevator.” As further explained by the panel:

As the history of the elevator’s dangerously defective operation is information concerning the physical condition of the property, which would certainly be material to a reasonable person notwithstanding any repair, and was clearly, in any event, important to plaintiffs given their questions as to its safety, we hold the broker defendants had a duty to disclose the information to them.

The court further noted that even if the elevator accident was considered a “psychological impairment,” the agents still had a duty to disclose the information to plaintiffs when they asked whether the elevator was safe.

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Related Posts

See all
Feedspot Names Government & Law Blog One of the Top Public Law Blogs post image

Feedspot Names Government & Law Blog One of the Top Public Law Blogs

FeedSpot Recognizes Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law Blog One of the Top 20 Public Law Blogs Little Falls, NJ – May 22, 2025 – Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC is honored to share that Managing Partner Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law blog has been listed by FeedSpot.com as one of the “20 Best Public Law Blogs and […]

Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

Link to post with title - "Feedspot Names Government & Law Blog One of the Top Public Law Blogs"
Scarinci Hollenbeck's Ron Bienstock Speaks at 100th Bomb Group's 2025 Reunion post image

Scarinci Hollenbeck's Ron Bienstock Speaks at 100th Bomb Group's 2025 Reunion

SH Partner and 100th Bomb Group Foundation Legal Counsel Discussed The Nuremberg Trials and the Law May 21, 2025 – Little Falls, NJ – Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC is proud to share that partner Ronald S. “Ron” Bienstock recently spoke at the 100th Bomb Group Biennial Reunion, held May 15-18, 2025, in New Orleans. The […]

Author: Ronald S. Bienstock

Link to post with title - "Scarinci Hollenbeck's Ron Bienstock Speaks at 100th Bomb Group's 2025 Reunion"
FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Constitutional Law Reporter One of the Top 100 Legal Blogs  post image

FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Constitutional Law Reporter One of the Top 100 Legal Blogs 

Little Falls, NJ – May 1, 2025 – Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC is proud to share that Managing Partner Donald Scarinci’s Constitutional Law Reporter blog has been listed by FeedSpot.com as one of the “Top 100 Legal Blogs.” No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Feedspot, a content reader that curates websites of […]

Author: Donald Scarinci

Link to post with title - "FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Constitutional Law Reporter One of the Top 100 Legal Blogs "
FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law Blog One of the Top 80 New Jersey Blogs  post image

FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law Blog One of the Top 80 New Jersey Blogs 

Little Falls, NJ – May 1, 2025 – Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC is proud to share that Managing Partner Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law blog has been listed by FeedSpot.com as one of the “80 Best New Jersey Blogs and Websites in 2025.” *No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New […]

Author: Donald Scarinci

Link to post with title - "FeedSpot Names Donald Scarinci’s Government & Law Blog One of the Top 80 New Jersey Blogs "
Nathanya G. Simon Named to ROI-NJ Influencers "Women in Business" 2025 List post image

Nathanya G. Simon Named to ROI-NJ Influencers "Women in Business" 2025 List

Scarinci Hollenbeck Partner Nathanya G. Simon named by ROI-NJ to the “ROI Influencers: Women in Business” list for fourth consecutive year Scarinci Hollenbeck Partner Nathanya G. Simon has been named by ROI-NJ to the “ROI Influencers: Women in Business” list for 2025. After four decades of practice, Nathanya’s pioneering influence in the field of special […]

Author: Nathanya G. Simon

Link to post with title - "Nathanya G. Simon Named to ROI-NJ Influencers "Women in Business" 2025 List"
SH Partner Angela Turiano Named Director of Legislative Affairs for SHRM Princeton post image

SH Partner Angela Turiano Named Director of Legislative Affairs for SHRM Princeton

Congratulations Angela Turiano on appointment as Director of Legislative Affairs for SHRM Princeton April 17, 2025 – Little Falls, NJ – Scarinci & Hollenbeck, LLC congratulates Partner Angela Turiano on her appointment as Director of Legislative Affairs for SHRM Princeton. Along with serving as a member of SHRM Princeton’s leadership team, Angela will monitor pending legislative, regulatory, […]

Author: Angela A. Turiano

Link to post with title - "SH Partner Angela Turiano Named Director of Legislative Affairs for SHRM Princeton"

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!

Explore What Matters Most to You.

Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

Let`s get in touch!

* The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!