Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm Insights

How to Make Sure Your Mediation Agreement Is Enforceable

Author: Ronald Lee Reisner

Date: April 25, 2023

Key Contacts

Back
How to Make Sure Your Mediation Agreement Is Enforceable

Mediation can be a quick and cost-effective means to resolve legal disputes. However, if your settlement agreement isn’t enforceable, all of these benefits will be lost…

Mediation can be a quick and cost-effective means to resolve legal disputes. However, if your settlement agreement isn’t enforceable, all of these benefits will be lost.

In New Jersey, a signed writing is essential for an enforceable mediation agreement. That means that if you reach a “handshake” deal during mediation, but don’t subsequently reduce the terms to writing and sign the written agreement, you can’t compel the other party to abide by its terms .

Bright-line Rule Requires Written Mediation Agreement

In Willingboro Mall, LTD. v. 240/242 Franklin Avenue, L.L.C., the New Jersey Supreme Court established a “bright-line rule” that parties to mediation in New Jersey must reduce their settlement agreement to writing in order for it to be enforceable. “[I]f the parties to mediation reach an agreement to resolve their dispute, the terms of that settlement must be reduced to writing and signed by the parties before the mediation comes to a close,” the court wrote.

The New Jersey Supreme Court further advised that in those cases in which the complexity of the settlement terms can’t be drafted by the time the mediation session was expected to have ended, the mediation session should be continued for a brief but reasonable period of time to allow for the signing of the settlement. The court also stated that it saw no reason why an audio- or video-recorded agreement would not meet the test of an agreement evidenced by a record signed by all parties to the agreement.

The New Jersey Supreme Court further held in Willingboro that mediation discussions can’t be used to prove an agreement was reached unless the parties waive the mediation privilege. “A settlement in mediation should not be the prelude to a new round of litigation over whether the parties reached a settlement,” the court wrote. “The signed, written agreement requirement — we expect – will greatly minimize the potential for litigation.”

Failure to Follow Bright Line Rule Renders Mediation Agreement Unenforceable

A recent Appellate Division decision highlights what can go wrong if both parties don’t sign the agreement in the wake of Willingboro. The court ruled that the sellers of two New Jersey nail salons were not bound by a draft settlement agreement that they later refused to sign.

The suit involved a dispute over the sale of two nail salons — Sharon Nails and Ceci Nails. The defendants made a $550,000 down payment and acquired possession of the salons, but the sales were not finalized after negotiations deteriorated. The plaintiffs filed suit, principally alleging breach of contract and breach of an agreement to purchase the nail salons. The defendants answered and filed a third-party complaint against Soon Wea Son, the manager of Ceci Nails, who resigned during the negotiations, and the new salon she opened, Graceful Nails of Brielle LLC, alleging contractual and tortious harm.

The parties voluntarily agreed to mediation. As a result of the mediation session, the mediator created a draft settlement agreement. Among other terms, the draft settlement provided that the plaintiffs would retain the $550,000 down payment and the defendants would retain possession of Sharon Nails but return possession of Ceci Nails, contingent upon Ceci Nails’ landlord consenting to assign its lease to plaintiffs by February 1, 2022.

 A few hours after the mediation ended, one of the plaintiffs informed her attorney she did not want to settle and did not sign the agreement, which was communicated to the defendants and the trial court. While the defendants took steps to move forward with the settlement, such as securing the lease assignment, the parties did not finalize the agreement by February 1, 2022, as required by the draft settlement. The defendants nonetheless sought to enforce the agreement, which both the trial court and the Appellate Division denied.

“The parties did not sign the draft settlement agreement and, therefore, it is unenforceable under Willingboro’s broad, bright-line rule,” the court wrote. The Appellate Division further held that Willingboro applies equally to all forms of mediation, rejecting the defendants’ argument that the decision did not apply to voluntary mediation. “In deciding this appeal, whether mediation is court-ordered or voluntary is a distinction without a difference,” the court wrote.

Key Elements of a Mediation Settlement Agreement

Signatures are not all you need for a binding settlement agreement. While mediation is less formal than traditional court proceedings, any settlement reached by the parties must meet the requirements of a binding legal contract.

The parties must also have a reached an agreement on the key terms in dispute. Accordingly, the agreement should set forth the responsibilities and obligations of the parties, and any compensation or payments must be paid pursuant to the settlement. The agreement must also state that each party is receiving something of value in exchange for the promises made in the agreement, which is known as “consideration.”

While not essential to a binding agreement, below are several other key components of a mediation settlement agreement:

  • Dispute Summary: A brief summary of the nature of the dispute.
  • Payment Provisions: A description of the payments that must be made by one party to the other.
  • Termination/Modification Provisions: The circumstances under which the agreement may be terminated or modified.
  • Confidentiality Provisions: Restrictions on the parties from disclosing the contents of the agreement to third parties.
  • Governing Law: A clause identifying the jurisdiction that will govern the interpretation and enforcement of the agreement.

Key Takeaway

Mediation can be an effective way to resolve complex and sensitive business disputes. However, in order to get the most out of it, it is important to understand how the process works and what steps must be taken to enforce any settlement.

At Scarinci Hollenbeck, we work closely with our clients to carefully evaluate whether mediation, arbitration, and other forms of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) can serve as a viable alternative to traditional court proceedings. When ADR is used, the attorneys of our Alternative Dispute Resolution Practice Group leverage their exceptional negotiation skills and decades of dispute resolution experience to resolve the matter. If you have any questions or if you would like to discuss the matter further, please contact me, Ronald Lee Reisner, J.S.C. (Ret.), or the Scarinci Hollenbeck attorney with whom you work, at 201-896-4100.

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Related Posts

See all
The Current Administration's Proposals for the Financial Services and Banking Industries Will Affect Your Business post image

The Current Administration's Proposals for the Financial Services and Banking Industries Will Affect Your Business

Since his inauguration two months ago, Donald Trump’s administration and the Congress it controls have indicated important upcoming policy changes. These changes will impact financial services policies and priorities. The changes will particularly affect cryptocurrency, as well as banking rules and regulations. Key Regulatory Changes in Cryptocurrency For example, in the burgeoning cryptocurrency business environment, […]

Author: Dan Brecher

Link to post with title - "The Current Administration's Proposals for the Financial Services and Banking Industries Will Affect Your Business"
Tips for Commercial Landlords Impacted by Wave of Retailer Bankruptcies Part 1 post image

Tips for Commercial Landlords Impacted by Wave of Retailer Bankruptcies Part 1

The retail sector has experienced a wave of bankruptcy filings over the last year. Brick-and-mortar businesses in financial distress include big-name brands like Big Lots, Party City, The Container Store, and Vitamin Shoppe. When large retailers seek bankruptcy protection, they are not the only businesses impacted. Landlords can be particularly hard hit. While commercial landlords […]

Author: Brian D. Spector

Link to post with title - "Tips for Commercial Landlords Impacted by Wave of Retailer Bankruptcies Part 1"
How Understanding Bankruptcy Trends Can Benefit Your Business post image

How Understanding Bankruptcy Trends Can Benefit Your Business

The bankruptcy legal landscape presents both challenges and opportunities for businesses navigating financial distress. Understanding current bankruptcy trends can help businesses make more informed and strategic decisions. Corporate Bankruptcy Filings Trending Upwards Bankruptcy filings continued to trend upwards in 2024. According to statistics released by the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, personal and business […]

Author: Brian D. Spector

Link to post with title - "How Understanding Bankruptcy Trends Can Benefit Your Business"
SEC Takes Actions Against Issuers for Failure to File Form D post image

SEC Takes Actions Against Issuers for Failure to File Form D

In December, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced charges against two privately held companies for failing to file a Form D notice, which is generally utilized for exempt securities offerings. Here, the SEC’s enforcement sends a strong message: compliance with regulatory requirements is not optional and failure to comply can have significant consequences. […]

Author: Kenneth C. Oh

Link to post with title - "SEC Takes Actions Against Issuers for Failure to File Form D"
Redefining Labor Relations: NLRB's Pivot from Abruzzo’s Memoranda post image

Redefining Labor Relations: NLRB's Pivot from Abruzzo’s Memoranda

On February 14, 2025, the Office of General Counsel (OGC) of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) under Acting General Counsel William B. Cowen issued Memorandum 25-05, “New Process for More Efficient, Effective, Accessible and Transparent Case handling.” The Memorandum rescinds nearly all of the Memoranda issued by his direct predecessor, Jennifer Abruzzo, setting the […]

Author: Matthew F. Mimnaugh

Link to post with title - "Redefining Labor Relations: NLRB's Pivot from Abruzzo’s Memoranda"
What Are FIRPTA Withholding Requirements? post image

What Are FIRPTA Withholding Requirements?

If you purchase real property from a foreign person or entity, you may be required to withhold taxes from your payment to the seller under the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act (FIRPTA). The federal tax law is designed to ensure that foreign sellers pay any applicable capital gains tax on profits realized from […]

Author: Jesse M. Dimitro

Link to post with title - "What Are FIRPTA Withholding Requirements?"

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!

Explore What Matters Most to You.

Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

Let`s get in touch!

* The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!

Please select a category(s) below: