Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLCScarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Firm Insights

NJ Appeals Court Deems Class Action Waiver Unenforceable Without Arbitration Deal 

Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC

Date: June 14, 2023

Key Contacts

Back
NJ Appeals Court Deems Class Action Waiver Unenforceable Without Arbitration Deal

Class action waivers are unenforceable without a mandatory arbitration agreement in place, according to a recent Appellate Division decision…

Class action waivers are unenforceable without a mandatory arbitration agreement in place, according to a recent Appellate Division decision. Businesses should review their lease agreements, customer contracts, website terms of agreement, and other legal documents and make any necessary changes in light of the new bright-line rule.

New Jersey Condo Dispute Over Lease Agreement

The dispute in William Pace and Robert Walters v. Hamilton Cove et al. centers on lease contracts entered by the tenants of defendant Hamilton Cove Apartments (collectively with other related entities, the “Defendants”), a luxury apartment complex in Weehawken. Representative plaintiffs William Pace and Robert Walters (Plaintiffs) contend that in its advertisements, brochures, and oral statements to prospective tenants, Hamilton Cove Apartments promised the apartment complex would have “elevated, 24/7 security.” During an April 2020 tour of the apartment complex, Defendant’s representative advised Pace that security personnel would be stationed 24/7 at a podium near each building’s entrance.

Upon moving into the apartments, Plaintiffs learned that the apartment complex’s security cameras did not function. In addition, a front desk greeter/mailroom attendant in building A was only stationed at the front of the building for part of the day. In a subsequent lawsuit asserting claims of common law fraud and violations of the Consumer Fraud Act (CFA) against their landlord, Plaintiffs allege Defendants engaged in an unconscionable business practice in violation of the CFA, and that tenants overpaid for the apartments because they did not receive the full value promised, constituting an ascertainable loss.

Plaintiffs sought class action status, with their putative class including all the tenants of Hamilton Cove Apartments. Defendants moved to dismiss Plaintiffs’ complaint for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, or, in the alternative, to strike Plaintiffs’ class action allegations. In support, Defendants argued that the leases were not contracts of adhesion, the class action waivers contained in the lease agreements were valid and enforceable, and a class action was not necessary to vindicate Plaintiffs’ interests. The trial court refused to dismiss the suit, concluding that Plaintiffs pleaded their fraud claims with the requisite specificity and had satisfied the requirements of a class action.

Appellate Division Rules Class Action Waiver Is Unenforceable

The Appellate Division affirmed. It held that a waiver of the right to maintain a class action is unenforceable absent a mandatory arbitration agreement.

In response to Defendants’ argument that class action waivers are enforceable so long as they are clear and unambiguous, the appeals court noted that in all of the cases cited by Defendants, the class action waiver was coupled with an arbitration agreement. As Judge Richard J. Geiger explained:

Here, in contrast, there was no agreement to arbitrate contractual disputes. Plaintiffs and the other tenants were free to litigate their contractual and fraud claims in court. Therefore, the policies favoring arbitration and encouraging enforcement of arbitration agreements, as expressed in section 2 of the [Federal Arbitration Act], do not apply and what the Supreme Court of the United States has said about class action waivers – because it was all intended to enhance the FAA’s arbitration policies – is irrelevant outside that context.

After determining that case law emanating from the FAA was inapplicable, the Appellate Division determined that New Jersey’s policy favoring class actions prevailed. “Considering our longstanding, fundamental public policy favoring class actions, we hold there is no societal interest in enforcing a class action waiver in a contract that does not contain a mandatory arbitration provision and conclude that the class action waivers in this case are unenforceable as a matter of law and public policy,” Judge Geiger wrote. “By adopting this bright-line rule, we advance the recognized benefits of class actions for both litigants and the courts.”

In this case, the Appellate Division found that assuming the facts alleged by Plaintiffs are true, a class action was “clearly favored” in the case. “Hundreds of tenants at Hamilton Cove are similarly affected by the lack of promised security,” Judge Geiger wrote. “Economic efficiency and judicial economy would be enhanced by the utilization of class action litigation, and inconsistent results would be avoided.”

Key Takeaway

The Appellate Division’s precedential decision create a new bright-line rule for class-action waivers under which they are unlikely to be enforced outside the arbitration context. To help ensure that your class action waivers will survive a legal challenge, it is essential that they be paired with a mandatory arbitration agreement.

If you have questions, please contact us

If you have any questions or if you would like to discuss the matter further, please contact the Scarinci Hollenbeck attorney with whom you work, at 201-896-4100 or contact us using the contact us form above.

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC, LLC

Related Posts

See all
How to Conduct a Fair and Legal Employee Termination in 2025 post image

How to Conduct a Fair and Legal Employee Termination in 2025

Ongoing economic uncertainty is forcing many companies to make tough decisions, which includes lowering staff levels. The legal landscape on both the state and federal level also continues to evolve, especially with significant changes to the priorities of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) under the Trump Administration. Terminating an employee is one of the […]

Author: Angela A. Turiano

Link to post with title - "How to Conduct a Fair and Legal Employee Termination in 2025"
Admin Dissolution for Annual Report: What You Need to Know post image

Admin Dissolution for Annual Report: What You Need to Know

While filing annual reports may seem like a nuisance, failing to do so can have significant ramifications. These include fines, reputational harm, and interruption of your business operations. In basic terms, “admin dissolution for annual report” means that a company is dissolved by the government. This happens because it failed to submit its annual report […]

Author: Dan Brecher

Link to post with title - "Admin Dissolution for Annual Report: What You Need to Know"
What Is Antitrust Litigation Law? post image

What Is Antitrust Litigation Law?

Antitrust laws are designed to ensure that businesses compete fairly. There are three federal antitrust laws that businesses must navigate. These include the Sherman Act, the Federal Trade Commission Act, and the Clayton Act. States also have their own antitrust regimes. These may vary from federal regulations. Understanding antitrust litigation helps businesses navigate these complex […]

Author: Robert E. Levy

Link to post with title - "What Is Antitrust Litigation Law?"
Dissolving Your Business: Essential Legal Steps to Protect Your Interests post image

Dissolving Your Business: Essential Legal Steps to Protect Your Interests

If you’re considering closing your business, it’s crucial to understand that simply shutting your doors does not end your legal obligations. Unless you formally dissolve your business, it continues to exist in the eyes of the law—leaving you exposed to ongoing liabilities such as taxes, compliance violations, and potential lawsuits. Dissolving a business can seem […]

Author: Christopher D. Warren

Link to post with title - "Dissolving Your Business: Essential Legal Steps to Protect Your Interests"
The Role of Corporate Restructuring in Mergers & Acquisitions post image

The Role of Corporate Restructuring in Mergers & Acquisitions

Contrary to what many people think, corporate restructuring isn’t all doom and gloom. Revamping a company’s organizational structure, corporate hierarchy, or operations procedures can help keep your business competitive. This is particularly true during challenging times. Corporate restructuring plays a critical role in modern business strategy. It helps companies adapt quickly to market changes. Following […]

Author: Dan Brecher

Link to post with title - "The Role of Corporate Restructuring in Mergers & Acquisitions"
Crypto Enforcement: A Former Prosecutor’s Warning to Criminals and the Public post image

Crypto Enforcement: A Former Prosecutor’s Warning to Criminals and the Public

Cryptocurrency intimidates most people. The reason is straightforward. People fear what they do not understand. When confusion sets in, the common reaction is either to ignore the subject entirely or to mistrust it. For years, that is exactly how most of the public and even many in law enforcement treated cryptocurrency. However, such apprehension changed […]

Author: Bryce S. Robins

Link to post with title - "Crypto Enforcement: A Former Prosecutor’s Warning to Criminals and the Public"

No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!

Explore What Matters Most to You.

Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.

Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.

Let`s get in touch!

* The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!