
Dan Brecher
Counsel
212-286-0747 dbrecher@sh-law.comFirm Insights
Author: Dan Brecher
Date: April 17, 2015
Counsel
212-286-0747 dbrecher@sh-law.comThe Court’s decision resolves the existing Circuit split and creates a new legal standard for future securities lawsuits.
The plaintiffs alleged that Omnicare, Inc. (“Omnicare”) violated Section 11 when it filed a registration statement that contained two statements expressing the company’s opinion that it was in compliance with federal and state laws. The federal government later sued Omnicare for allegedly receiving kickbacks from pharmaceutical manufacturers and pension funds that purchased the company’s stock. Section 11 creates a cause of action for investors who have acquired securities under a registration statement that either “contain[s] an untrue statement of a material fact” or “omit[s] to state a material fact . . . necessary to make the statements therein not misleading.”
The District Court granted Omnicare’s motion to dismiss after finding that the plaintiff failed to allege that Omnicare’s officers knew they were violating the law. The Sixth Circuit reversed, holding that Section 11 provides for strict liability and, therefore, the defendant’s state of mind is irrelevant. According to the appeals court, “Once a false statement has been made, a defendant’s knowledge is not relevant to a strict liability claim.”
The Supreme Court vacated the Sixth Circuit’s decision, holding that the court’s holding “wrongly conflates facts and opinions.” Given that the lower court applied the incorrect legal standard, the Supreme Court remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion.
In reaching its decision, the Supreme Court analyzed Section 11’s two clauses independently. With regard to statements of opinion, the Court clarified that a statement of opinion does not constitute an “untrue statement of . . . fact” simply because the stated opinion ultimately proves incorrect. Rather, the Court held that “a statement of opinion thus qualifies as an ‘untrue statement of . . . fact’ if that fact is untrue—i.e., if the opinion expressed was not sincerely held.”
As for the omissions clause, the Court held that Section 11 liability may arise if a registration statement omits material facts about the issuer’s inquiry into, or knowledge concerning, a statement of opinion, and if those facts conflict with what a reasonable investor, reading the statement fairly and in context, would take from the statement.
“A reasonable investor may, depending on the circumstances, understand an opinion statement to convey facts about how the speaker has formed the opinion — or, otherwise put, about the speaker’s basis for holding that view,” Justice Elena Kagan explained. “And if the real facts are otherwise, but not provided, the opinion statement will mislead its audience.”
Because the lower courts failed to apply the correct legal standard to the plaintiff’s omissions claim, the Supreme Court remanded the case with the following instructions: “The court must review the Funds’ complaint to determine whether it adequately alleges that Omnicare omitted from the registration statement some specific fact that would have been material to a reasonable investor. If so, the court must decide whether the alleged omission rendered Omnicare’s opinion statements misleading in context.”
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
The Trump Administration’s new tariffs are having an oversized impact on small businesses, which already tend to operate on razor thin margins. Many businesses have been forced to raise prices, find new suppliers, lay off staff, and delay growth plans. For businesses facing even more dire financial circumstances, there are additional tariff response options, including […]
Author: Brian D. Spector
Business partnerships, much like marriages, function exceptionally well when partners are aligned but can become challenging when disagreements arise. Partnership disputes often stem from conflicts over business strategy, financial management, and unclear role definitions among partners. Understanding Business Partnership Conflicts Partnership conflicts place significant stress on businesses, making proactive measures essential. Partnerships should establish detailed […]
Author: Christopher D. Warren
*** The original article was featured on Bloomberg Tax, April 28, 2025 — As a tax attorney who spends much of my time helping people and companies who have large, unresolved issues with the IRS or one or more state tax departments, it often occurs to me that the best service that I can provide […]
Author: Scott H. Novak
On January 28, 2025, the Trump Administration terminated Gwynne Wilcox from her position as a Member of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB or the Board). Gwynne Wilcox, a union side lawyer for Levy Ratner, was confirmed to the Board for an original term in 2021 and confirmed again for a successive five-year term expiring […]
Author: Matthew F. Mimnaugh
Breach of contract disputes are the most common type of business litigation. Therefore, nearly all New York and New Jersey businesses will likely have to deal with a contract dispute at least once. Understanding when to file a breach of contract lawsuit and how long you have to sue for breach of contract is essential […]
Author: Brittany P. Tarabour
Closing your business can be a difficult and challenging task. For corporations, the process includes formal approval of the dissolution, winding up operations, resolving tax liabilities, and filing all required paperwork. Whether you need to understand how to dissolve a corporation in New York or New Jersey, it’s imperative to take all of the proper […]
Author: Christopher D. Warren
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
Let`s get in touch!
Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!