The Firm
201-896-4100 info@sh-law.comFirm Insights
NY Federal Court Rules Auditors Strictly Liable for Their “Opinions”
Author: Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC
Date: September 23, 2013
Ernst & Young and PriceWaterhouseCoopers will not be dismissed from the securities class-action lawsuit involving Overseas Shipholding Group, Inc. (OSG). The two firms provided auditing services to the now defunct company.
The case revolves around OSG’s public offering of three hundred million dollars of unsecured notes. In connection with the transaction, OSG filed a Shelf Registration Statement and Prospectus that allegedly failed to disclose tax liability under Section 956 of Section F of the Internal Revenue Code.
Both Ernst & Young and PriceWaterhouseCoopers signed the Registration Statement. They also “expressly consented to having their unqualified audit opinions for OSG’s financial statements [for years 2007 through 2009] incorporated by reference into the Registration Statement.” OSG later filed for bankruptcy, which included an Internal Revenue Service claim of $35 million in unpaid corporate taxes.
Under Section 11 of the Securities Act, purchasers of registered securities are afforded strict liability protection where “any part of the registration statement, when such part became effective, contained an untrue statement of a material fact or omitted to state a material fact required to be stated therein or necessary to make the statements therein not misleading.” Experts like accountants may specifically be held liable if they certified any part of the Registration Statement containing actionably false information or “prepared any report or valuation used in connection with the registration statement.”
However, with regard to “matters of belief and opinion,” Section 11 liability applies only where the statement was “both objectively false and disbelieved by the defendant at the time it was expressed” under the recent precedent established in Fait v. Regions Financial Corp. In the current case, Ernst & Young and PriceWaterhouseCoopers argued that Fait’s subjective disbelief standard should apply to their auditing “opinions.” However, the court disagreed.
As explained in Judge Shira Scheindlin’s opinion, “Although the Internal Revenue Code is complex and often gives rise to debate, it cannot be said that statements of income tax liability are ‘subjective valuations.’ There is in fact an objective measure of income tax liability, as evidenced by OSG’s public declaration that its financial statements should ‘no longer be relied upon,’ as well as the IRS’s Proof of Claim in OSG’s bankruptcy proceedings.”
Judge Scheindlin further rejected the auditors’ assertion that the entire Audit Opinion is a statement of belief or opinion under Fait because it contains the word “opinion” in its title, and prefaces its conclusions with the phrase “in our opinion.”
“[I]t would render Section 11 meaningless to find that an accountant’s liability turns on this semantic choice. Auditors may not shield themselves from liability under Section 11 merely by using the word ‘opinion’ as a disclaimer. Plaintiffs are only required to allege subjective disbelief where the statements concern ‘inherently subjective’ matters rather than ‘matters of objective fact,’” she concluded.
If you have any questions about this case or would like to discuss the legal issues involved, please contact me, Michael Cifelli, or the Scarinci Hollenbeck attorney with whom you work.
- Practices: Corporate Transactions & Business, Financial Services & Regulatory Practice, Litigation, Commercial Litigation - Business Litigation Attorney
- Locations: New York City, Red Bank, NJ, Little Falls, NJ
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

Federal gift tax rules allow individuals to transfer significant assets to loved ones without incurring gift taxes, but taking full advantage of these opportunities requires an understanding of the applicable limits and deadlines. With the annual gift tax exclusion set to increase in 2027, now is a good time to review the current rules and […]
Author: Marc J. Comer

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are being developed throughout New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, with much of the legal attention focused on zoning approvals, permitting, interconnection, and safety requirements. Far less attention has been paid to what happens when these facilities reach the end of their operating lives. For developers and property owners entering […]
Author: Nicholas Wall

While most estate and trust administrations conclude without significant complications, disagreements can arise over expenses, fiduciary commissions, distributions, and other aspects of the administration. Understanding the steps involved, as well as the fiduciary’s legal obligations, can help avoid unnecessary disputes and bring the administration to a successful conclusion. Key Takeaways Keeping Beneficiaries Informed Throughout the […]
Author: Marc J. Comer

A Fort Monmouth redevelopment agreement imposes obligations beyond a traditional property purchase, including construction deadlines, financial commitments, permitted uses, and restrictions on future transfers. Fort Monmouth’s ongoing redevelopment presents significant opportunities for real estate developers, investors, and businesses seeking to establish or expand their presence in Monmouth County. However, acquiring and developing property at the […]
Author: Donald M. Pepe

As battery energy storage system (BESS) projects move from planning to construction, developers and property owners must address an issue that extends well beyond zoning approvals and interconnection agreements: what happens when something goes wrong? To avoid unforeseen liability, developers should address fire code compliance, emergency response planning, contractual risk allocation, and environmental liability before […]
Author: Nicholas Wall

Case law following the 2010 amendments to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 offers guidance on how courts are likely to address whether an expert witness’s AI records are subject to discovery. Key Takeaways Rule 26 Expert Discovery After the 2010 Amendments This article addresses the question courts and lawyers have faced in recent cases: […]
Author: Chris Seelinger
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
