Abusive Landlord Hit With Emotional Distress and Punitive Damage Award By Bankruptcy Court
A recent decision by the Third Circuit should serve as a clear warning to overly-aggressive landlords who are dealing with bankrupt tenants. In Lansaw v Zokaites (In re Lansaw) U.S. App. Lexis 6121 (3d Cir. 2017), the appellate court affirmed awards of emotional distress damages and punitive damages against a landlord who demonstrably went way over the line in dealing with his bankrupt tenants.
Debtors Garth and Deborah Lansaw operated a daycare center in premises owned by Frank Zokaites. Disputes arose, and the Lansaws signed a lease with a different landlord. Zokaites did not take this well and served a notice of distraint, claiming a lien against the Lansaws’ property for unpaid rent. The Lansaws responded by filing bankruptcy.
Under §362 of the Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. §362, filing a bankruptcy automatically causes an injunction (the so-called “automatic stay”) to go into effect. This automatic stay forbids any party from pursuing any action against the debtor or against the debtor’s property.** A willful violation of the automatic stay is a contempt of court and subjects the creditor to actual damages and, in appropriate circumstances, punitive damages.
The Incident(s) In Question
Zokaites’ actions went way over this bright line. First, after the bankruptcy was filed, he arrived at the Daycare premises during business hours, entered the office of Mrs. Lansaw, backed her against the wall close enough for her to feel his breath, and repeatedly asked her “Do you want to hit me?” Next, he visited the premises after business hours and padlocked the door. When the Lansaws removed the chains, he took their keys, including personal keys, and left the premises. Finally, Zokaites got in touch with the new landlord and threatened him with a complaint if he would not terminate his lease with the Lansaws.
Issue Before the Third Circuit
The Third Circuit noted that §362(k) of the Bankruptcy Code provides that an individual injured by a willful violation of the automatic stay may recover actual damages “and, in appropriate circumstances, may recover punitive damages.” The issue before the court, however, was whether the term “actual damages” included the emotional distress damages which the Lansaws had sought. The court concluded that Congress intended the automatic stay to protect both financial and nonfinancial interests. It, therefore, joined “a growing number of circuits” in determining that emotional distress damages resulting from a willful violation of the automatic stay were in fact contemplated by the statute. Moreover, the court declined to require corroborating medical evidence in all cases of emotional distress damages, finding sufficient evidence of emotional distress in Zokaites’ actions. As the Court noted:
“But, at least where the evidence also shows that the stay violations were patently egregious, a plaintiff’s credible testimony that the violations did in fact cause emotional distress is sufficient to support an award of damages.”
The court therefore affirmed an award of $7500 for emotional distress damages and further affirmed a $40,000 award for punitive damages – all based upon Zokaites’ conduct.
The Bottom Line
All creditors get significantly annoyed, if not violently angry when their playmates and other business contacts go bankrupt on them. Nevertheless, caution should always be exercised. Bankruptcy judges take very seriously their obligation to protect the interests of debtors, and actions that go over the line will invariably draw the court’s ire. It’s always best to seek competent bankruptcy counsel from an attorney and not to let your spleen dictate your actions.
Are you a creditor in a bankruptcy? Have you been sued by a bankrupt? If you have any questions about your rights, please contact me, Joel Glucksman, at 201-806-3364.
**The quip used in bankruptcy circles is, “If you’re thinking of taking any action against a bankrupt, and what you’re thinking of doing might tend to make you smile, DON’T DO IT!” You’ll find yourself standing before a federal judge, who will politely ask if you have your toothbrush in your pocket (because you’re not going to be sleeping at home that night).
A Whistleblower Just Filed a Complaint Against Your Company: Here's What to Do Now
Few situations create more uncertainty than learning that an employee has filed a whistleblower complaint. Questions arise immediately: Is the allegation legitimate? Should the employee be placed on leave? Do we need to notify our insurance carrier? Are we now prevented from disciplining the employee if there are unrelated ongoing work related issues? There is […]
Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors: An Alternative to Bankruptcy for Distressed Businesses
When a business reaches the point where it can no longer service its debts or otherwise resolve its liabilities, management is often faced with a difficult question: is a bankruptcy filing necessary or is there another way to perform an orderly liquidation or sale of the business assets? While Chapters 7 and 11 of the […]
Breaking Down New Jersey’s “Mansion” Tax: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know
For many years, the New Jersey Mansion Tax has been a significant consideration in high-value real estate transactions. Recent legislative changes, however, have substantially altered how the tax operates, including who is responsible for paying it and the amount owed in certain transactions. Whether you are purchasing, selling, or investing in New Jersey real estate, […]
Estate Planning for Digital Assets Under New Jersey Law
As our personal and financial lives increasingly move online, estate planning must evolve to address a new category of property: digital assets. From email accounts and social media profiles to cryptocurrency and cloud-stored business records, these assets often carry both financial and sentimental value. Yet, without proper planning, they can become inaccessible—or even lost—upon incapacity […]
The Role of Representation and Warranty Insurance in M&A Transactions
In today’s mergers and acquisitions market, representation and warranty (R&W) insurance has become a common feature of deal negotiations. Once used primarily in larger transactions, R&W insurance is now frequently incorporated into middle-market deals as buyers and sellers look for efficient ways to allocate risk and close deals. When structured properly, R&W insurance can help […]
You Just Received a Federal Grand Jury Subpoena in New Jersey: Now What?
Receiving a federal grand jury subpoena is not something most businesses or individuals anticipate. While it can be concerning, a federal grand jury subpoena does not necessarily mean that you are being accused of wrongdoing. It does, however, mean that a federal criminal investigation is underway and that federal prosecutors believe you may possess information […]
No Aspect of the advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.
Sign up to get the latest from our attorneys!
Explore What Matters Most to You.
Consider subscribing to our Firm Insights mailing list by clicking the button below so you can keep up to date with the firm`s latest articles covering various legal topics.
Stay informed and inspired with the latest updates, insights, and events from Scarinci Hollenbeck. Our resource library provides valuable content across a range of categories to keep you connected and ahead of the curve.
Let`s get in touch!
Sign up to get the latest from the Scarinci Hollenbeck, LLC attorneys!
